Jim Kukral: 99.5 Percent Of All Wordpress Themes Suck
Terry Ng
· 2 years ago
Jim -
Give me a holla! Maybe I can be of help. ;)
AndyBeard
· 2 years ago
Actually from an SEO & loading order perspective I don't like Yaro's theme, because the header links and left sidebar load before the content.
Jim Kukral
· 2 years ago
Andy, I hear what you're saying, but I don't agree with your assessment that design has much to do with seo at all. Sure, it does do small stuff, but no, I haven't seen any evidence to show me that good quality content is in any way hindrance'd by an improper blog layout.
Good content wins, period. Now if your content stinks, then yeah, maybe you need to have a special built seo theme :)
Jim Kukral
· 2 years ago
@Terry, pinged! Thanks yo! Can't wait to see what you come up with.
AndyBeard
· 2 years ago
Well of course it is important to have all your sidebar content, advertising and widgets load before your content.
His page doesn't have an H1 heading, so the first heading that the google spider sees is "Featured Sites"
When Revenews appears in Megite (or at least appeared, no article up there to check atm), what was typically seen was the picture and bio from the left hand column. Spiders have difficulty parsing pages that have the left column first.
Sites using widgets in their sidebars experience horrible problems with loading time of their content if they don't have the content first. A VC used to have this problem, they don't anymore. Last time I looked, Marketing Pilgrim still had the problem, with both right hand sidebars loading first. I don't know why spiders didn't have problems finding the content.
If you are using a free theme, you get what you pay for. If you are paying for a custom theme for a good designer, you expect it to be well designed, not just look nice.
Yaro
· 2 years ago
This may seem callous - and I know my site could use more SE optimization - but I find if the links keep coming in to my site Google decides my content is great and ranks it well, no matter where it appears in my page layout and whether the syntax is perfect for SEO.
I have a list of tweaks I'd like to do to my design, but technically they are way beyond me. Theme design changes are not a priority at the moment, so I'll just keep relying on good content to get me there. I'm happy enough just having a "bad-ass" design :)
AndyBeard
· 2 years ago
Yaro - it is not callous at all, there are so many things wrong with my own site markup currently and I just haven't fixed it yet. Part of that is just general time restraints, part is because of gradual testing, and partly because each time I make a change, I want to use it as an example.
Any criticism I suppose can be directed to theme designers in general who don't think about these things.
Here is another interesting thread to read on some similar issues that are prevalent in most themes.
You don't have to dish out $3-5k for a great Wordpress theme, Jim. There's a bunch of talented designers that are willing to work for less than that. Be wary though, if you require special solutions you should go with a pro...
DarrinW
· 2 years ago
Jim, look forward to seeing your new layout if you do get one :)
Jim Kukral
· 2 years ago
@TDH... You're right. But the ones that I know of charge that much. If you charge less, I'd like to know you :)
@Darrin... Yes, so do I! Terry has graciously decided to help me with a theme. Someday you might see something new up here.
Sam Harrelson
· 2 years ago
I think it's interesting that so many of the top Technorati 100 don't seem to care about things such as design or templates. We've had this convo off blog, Jim... but it is interesting to me that Scoble, Winer, Godin and even Rubel rely on either minimalist design or Wordpress.com/Typepad.com default styles. Scoble is still using a .wordpress.com site and he's the king blogger.
I've gone hyper-minimalist with my personal blog and do enjoy the freedom and the white space. Not sure what to do with CPN, though...
Great topic!
Jim Kukral
· 2 years ago
Wow, your comment went through Sam! You must have gotten out of the Akismet bad karma ring.
I am a self admitted design snob and visual thinker. So design is very important to me and my brand, and what I consider to be important. I know that in reality design means nothing if the content is high-quality (Ex: Scoble/Winer), but in the back of my head, I want the full experience... I want a good design too.
I like minimalist too. My problem is I have so much stuff to showcase that I want to get it all into one design, and it's impossible.
andrew wee
· 2 years ago
I'd suggest to go with content, content, content.
Unless we're professional designers, I don't think a 'pretty' design should factor at all.
But the layout at least has to be intuitive and not leave me wondering where the heck the archives are at.
some basic stuff like sorting out your permalink structure, including commonsensical plugins like most popular posts and recent comments, into a decent template do it for me.
Da Brazilian Gangsta
· 1 year ago
I agree with the title of this post. Most of them simply suck. :(
All Comments
Give me a holla! Maybe I can be of help. ;)
Good content wins, period. Now if your content stinks, then yeah, maybe you need to have a special built seo theme :)
His page doesn't have an H1 heading, so the first heading that the google spider sees is "Featured Sites"
When Revenews appears in Megite (or at least appeared, no article up there to check atm), what was typically seen was the picture and bio from the left hand column. Spiders have difficulty parsing pages that have the left column first.
Sites using widgets in their sidebars experience horrible problems with loading time of their content if they don't have the content first.
A VC used to have this problem, they don't anymore. Last time I looked, Marketing Pilgrim still had the problem, with both right hand sidebars loading first. I don't know why spiders didn't have problems finding the content.
If you are using a free theme, you get what you pay for. If you are paying for a custom theme for a good designer, you expect it to be well designed, not just look nice.
I have a list of tweaks I'd like to do to my design, but technically they are way beyond me. Theme design changes are not a priority at the moment, so I'll just keep relying on good content to get me there. I'm happy enough just having a "bad-ass" design :)
Any criticism I suppose can be directed to theme designers in general who don't think about these things.
Here is another interesting thread to read on some similar issues that are prevalent in most themes.
http://www.pearsonified.com/2007/04/definitive-...
@Darrin... Yes, so do I! Terry has graciously decided to help me with a theme. Someday you might see something new up here.
I've gone hyper-minimalist with my personal blog and do enjoy the freedom and the white space. Not sure what to do with CPN, though...
Great topic!
I am a self admitted design snob and visual thinker. So design is very important to me and my brand, and what I consider to be important. I know that in reality design means nothing if the content is high-quality (Ex: Scoble/Winer), but in the back of my head, I want the full experience... I want a good design too.
I like minimalist too. My problem is I have so much stuff to showcase that I want to get it all into one design, and it's impossible.
Unless we're professional designers, I don't think a 'pretty' design should factor at all.
But the layout at least has to be intuitive and not leave me wondering where the heck the archives are at.
some basic stuff like sorting out your permalink structure, including commonsensical plugins like most popular posts and recent comments, into a decent template do it for me.